| SPORTSCASTERS | | | |
| YEAR | WINNER | NAME | AFFIL |
| 2024 | Jody | Jackson | MLB/D'backs TV, Cardinals Radio - 98.7, Phoenix |
| 2023 | Greg | Schulte | Arizona Diamondbacks, Phoenix |
| 2022 | Jody | Jackson | Bally Sports Arizona, Phoenix |
| 2021 | Al | McCoy | Suns Radio Network/KTAR, Phoenix |
| 2020 | Dave | Pasch | Arizona Cardinals Radio Network/ESPN, Phoenix |
| 2019 | Dave | Pasch | Arizona Cardinals Radio Network/ESPN, Phoenix |
| 2018 | Jeff | Munn | ASU Women's Basketball (Radio) |
| 2017 | Dave | Pasch | Arizona Cardinals Radio Network, Phoenix |
| 2016 | Tim | Healey | Sun Devil Radio Network, Tempe |
| 2015 | Tim | Healey | Sun Devil Radio Network, Tempe |
| 2014 | Dave | Pasch | Arizona Cardinals/ESPN, Phoenix |
| 2013 | Matt | McConnell | Phoenix Coyotes TV/Fox Sports Arizona, Phoenix |
| 2012 | Dave | Pasch | Arizona Cardinals/ESPN, Phoenix |
| 2011 | Tim | Ring | KTVK-TV |
| 2010 | Jeff | Munn | Arizona Diamondbacks |
| 2009 | No Winner | |
| 2008 | Tom | Dillon | Arizona State University, Fox Sports Network |
| 2007 | Tom | Dillon | Arizona State University, Fox Sports Network |
| 2006 | No Winner | |
| 2005 | Thom | Brennaman | Arizona Diamondbacks, Phoenix |
| 2004 | Thom | Brennaman | Arizona Diamondbacks, Phoenix |
| 2004 | Thom | Dillon | Dillon International, Phoenix |
| 2003 | Brett | Dolan | Tuscon Sidewinders |
| 2002 | Brett | Dolan | Tuscon Sidewinders |
| 2001 | Thom | Brennaman | Arizona Diamondbacks, Phoenix |
| 2000 | Thom | Brennaman | Arizona Diamondbacks, Phoenix |
| 1999 | Tom | Dillon | Arizona Cardinals, Phoenix |
| 1998 | No Winner | |
| 1997 | No Winner | |
| 1996 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1995 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1994 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1993 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1992 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1991 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1990 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1990 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1989 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1988 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1987 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1986 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1985 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1984 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1983 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1982 | Tom | Dillon | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1981 | Tom | Dillon | KARZ, Phoenix |
| 1980 | Dan | Faber | KCLS, Flagstaff |
| 1979 | Al | McCoy | Phoenix Suns |
| 1978 | Al | McCoy | Phoenix Suns |
| 1977 | Al | McCoy | KXIV, Phoenix |
| 1976 | Al | McCoy | KXIV, Phoenix |
| 1975 | Al | McCoy | Phoenix Suns |
| 1974 | Al | McCoy | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1973 | Al | McCoy | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1972 | Bob | Davies | KOOL, Phoenix |
| 1971 | Al | McCoy | KXIV, Phoenix |
| 1970 | Al | McCoy | KXIV, Phoenix |
| 1969 | Bob | Vache | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1968 | Al | McCoy | KOOL, Phoenix |
| 1967 | Bob | Vache | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1966 | Bob | Vache | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1965 | Bob | Vache | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1964 | Jack | Beveridge | KOOL, Phoenix |
| 1963 | Bob | Vache | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1962 | Al | McCoy | KRUX, Phoenix |
| 1961 | Bob | Vache | KTAR, Phoenix |
| 1960 | Jim | Officer | KTUC, Tucson |
| 1959 | Bill | Close | KOY, Phoenix |
| | | | |
| SPORTSWRITERS | | | |
| YEAR | WINNER | NAME | AFFIL |
| 2024 | Craig | Morgan | PHNX, Phoenix |
| 2023 | Kent | Somers | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2022 | Doug | Haller | The Athletic, Phoenix |
| | Craig | Morgan | PHNX, Phoenix |
| 2021 | Jeff | Metcalfe | Arizona Republic/azcentral.com, Phoenix |
| 2020 | Doug | Haller | The Athletic, Phoenix |
| 2020 | Kent | Somers | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2019 | Caitlin | Schmidt | Arizona Daily Star, Tuscon |
| 2019 | Doug | Haller | The Athletic, Phoenix |
| 2018 | Nick | Piecoro | Arizona Republic |
| 2017 | Doug | Haller | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2016 | Paul | Coro | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2015 | Paul | Coro | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2014 | Kent | Somers | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2013 | Kent | Somers | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2012 | Doug | Haller | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2011 | Paula | Boivin | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2010 | Paul | Coro | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2009 | No Winner | |
| 2008 | No Winner | |
| 2007 | No Winner | |
| 2006 | No Winner | |
| 2005 | Greg | Hansen | The Arizona Daily Star, Tucson |
| 2004 | Bob | Moran | East Valley Tribune, MESA |
| 2004 | Kent | Somers | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 2003 | Bob | Moran | East Valley Tribune, MESA |
| 2002 | Bob | Moran | East Valley Tribune, MESA |
| 2001 | Bob | Moran | East Valley Tribune, MESA |
| 2000 | Bob | Moran | East Valley Tribune, MESA |
| 1999 | No Winner | |
| 1998 | No Winner | |
| 1997 | Bob | Moran | The Mesa Tribune |
| 1996 | David | Casstevens | The Republic/ Gazette, Phoenix |
| 1995 | David | Casstevens | The Republic/ Gazette, Phoenix |
| 1994 | Bob | Moran | The Mesa Tribune |
| 1993 | Bob | Eger | The Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1992 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1991 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1990 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1989 | Bob | Eger | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1988 | Bob | Eger | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1987 | Bob | Eger | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1986 | Bob | Eger | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1985 | Bob | Eger | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1984 | Norm | Frauenheim | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1983 | Bob | Moran | The Arizona Daily Star |
| 1982 | Bob | Eger | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1981 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1980 | Corky | Simpson | Tucson Citizen |
| 1979 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1978 | Dave | Hicks | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1977 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1976 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1975 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1974 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1973 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1972 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1971 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1970 | Dave | Hicks | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1969 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1968 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1967 | Dave | Hicks | Phoenix Arizona Republic |
| 1966 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1965 | Joe | Gilmartin | The Phoenix Gazette |
| 1964 | Dave | Hicks | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1963 | Frank | Gianelli | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1962 | George | McLeod | Tucson Citizen |
| 1961 | Arnott | Duncan | Arizona Republic, Phoenix |
| 1960 | Ben | Foote | Phoenix Gazette |
| 1959 | Bob | Allison | Phoenix Gazette |
